Home
Bad Poetry, Ranting, and Geekiness - Divide And Conquor: Race [entries|archive|friends|userinfo]
Shug Jakey-Jake

[ userinfo | livejournal userinfo ]
[ archive | journal archive ]

Divide And Conquor: Race [Mar. 24th, 2008|06:03 pm]
Previous Entry Add to Memories Tell a Friend Next Entry

I am not going to be able to begin to properly address this issue in the 5 minutes I am stealing to post this, but I will do my best.

One of the more frustrating parts of my job is the level of success that the bosses of unionized employees often utilize in order to keep their workers divided and unable to resist their policies.  It is my job, then, to overcome these divisions, and get everyone in the shop to start thinking as a unit.  When it happens, it is the best high in the world.  While you're doing the long process, though, it can be infuriating.

I have spent some time thinking about prejudice amogst people of color.  These past few weeks, there has been a frequent occurrance of prejudice against certain racial or cultural groups by people who claim to speak for their whole department, culture, etc, and it has been a tough edge to walk.  On one hand, I understand the frustrations of the workers, especially when management has been seen to outsource jobs to lower-paid workers of a different ethnicity.  Moreover, I think that prejudice amongst different people of color is more complicated than say, Chaz Frat Guy says the same things.  In the end, it's still wrong, but macroscopically, somewhat different.  (I can't get into a detailed explanation just now) 

The RL example that prompted this post, is that a few individuals claiming to speak for every Spanish-speaking person in the building (at least 1/2 of the workers) that there is a rift between the Spanish-speaking union memebers and the outsourced Agency folks, who are predominantly from the Phillippeans.   There is also a huge element of anti-semetism, going so far as to question my loyalty to the union since "I look like a Jew and have a Jewish name" and that Jewish folks happen to run a lot of the facilities that we oversee.  Obviously, the people speaking are very frustrated with Management who is taking advantage of them, and the Union, which has dropped the fucking ball on their workers in almost every conceivable way.  It was the first time I had encountered this in this job position, and I am sad to say that I didn't do much to challenge people.  I did keep it professional by mentioning that everyone is potentially their Union Sister or Brother, and that they need to stick together, as everyone is being screwed.  It is also obvious that some folks besides these 3 bigots need to be involved in this process...

Anyway, in my mind, this is just The Man working here.   A common colonial tactic is to separate racial groups, and then treat them differently.  While it isn't perhaps overtly on the basis of race, I do see how it is aggrivating an already bad situaiton - and in the end, it only benefits the boss.

And so much of the youth wonder if they'll ever get a job where anti-racist training is relevant.  If only they'd realize that it is relevant and NEEDED at any sort of job, club, or social situation they participate in.

I want to take the time to address this divide and conquor, since really, it is the fundamental example of why unions and organizing work - people united cannot be isolated, and people united have power.  I need to get back to work though.

I apologize that I wasn't able to get too deeply into this, and that I frankly haven't even re-read what I am about to post.  But I am hoping that at least by putting something out there, some folks can witness and perhaps ponder what I have been pondering.

In solidarity,

Peace Love Respect.

linkReply

Comments:
[User Picture]From: secret_stuff
2008-03-25 12:42 pm (UTC)

(Link)

Very interesting commentary!

The only thing I wonder about, is whether there is any difference where motivation is involved? By which I mean, there is "racism" that is clear cut - Bill hates black people, or Steve thinks that anyone who doesn't speak English should be ejected from the country. But if what you are talking about is economic discrimination - Boss just wants to make money, and doesn't really care about race (ie he'd be perfectly happy to exploit white people, black people, children, anyone he could get away with exploiting) and playing on race is just a convenient tool... is it the same thing?

I tend to think not, because the underlying motives that need to be addressed are different, but your perspective might vary.
[User Picture]From: [info]mrdisgruntled
2008-03-25 04:39 pm (UTC)

(Link)

It's unfortunate that Newton was right; that every action creates an equal and opposite reaction. The stronger unions get, so do the union busting techniques get better in response. Sadly, it's what makes your job necessary. Fortunately, you're good at it. :)
[User Picture]From: [info]mrdisgruntled
2008-03-25 04:40 pm (UTC)

(Link)

Sorry, secret_stuff, that wasn't meant as a response to you; I clicked the wrong button.
[User Picture]From: secret_stuff
2008-03-25 04:52 pm (UTC)

(Link)

No worries, I figured as much :-)
[User Picture]From: [info]triplee
2008-03-26 06:39 pm (UTC)

(Link)

It's insane reading your accounts of the campaign up there, because there's just so many issues flying in at once.

Bigotry of any stripe is certainly bad, yet it's funny how society seems to accept that white, straight, vaguely Christian Americans will have some level of it, yet bigotry by anyone outside that mold is the elephant in the room that nobody talks about. When I run into things like homophobia and anti-Semitism in the African-American community, strife between African-Americans and Hispanics, Asian-Americans distrustful of anyone who's not Asian or white, children of immigrants who dislike new immigrants, etc., all of the above distrustful of Muslims, etc. it frankly is sometimes too much for me to deal with mentally. As you say, it's a different, yet highly similar beast, most of it stemming from the same place. That doesn't make it any harder for me to swallow, because the worldview myself and most in my place have grown up with just doesn't account for such things.

You're doing good work up there, because really, the situation you describe is no different than pitting the Irish against slaves/free blacks/sharecroppers in the 1800's. Both were underclasses in some respect, but treatment was just different enough to keep the two from realizing they were both being screwed and doing something about it.

On the flip side, it's a damn shame these people have a union that, until now, hasn't done shit for them. Doing a horrible job that nobody wants and being split up my management is bad enough, but when the people who are supposed to help you don't do anything, it's a real shame. Hat's off to you for being part of the solution.

~EEE~
[User Picture]From: secret_stuff
2008-03-27 01:46 pm (UTC)

Good points

(Link)

I personally believe that a certain base level of prejudice is just endemic to the human condition, and will never be completely eradicated (barring something over the top like the appearance of an extraterrestrial race). The trick is to mitigate and minimize it as much as possible.

I suspect the elephant in the room comes from the idea that slavery and treatment of african americans in US history went so far beyond the 'normal' levels of discrimination one might find 'naturally' in society that its uncomfortable to try and compare them.
[User Picture]From: [info]triplee
2008-03-28 05:06 pm (UTC)

Re: Good points

(Link)

Yeah, I don't like the idea that there's always going to be some sort of underclass, but really, thousands of years of history has shown that to be the case. Even progressive Western Europe has issues with North Africans, Eastern Europeans, Asians, etc. That's no excuse not to work to change it, and especially doesn't mean we can't foster the opportunity to get the hell out of being in an underclass, but it does need to be recognized as such.

I once heard someone say that it takes ten positive actions to wipe out the effects of one negative one. It's a bit of a crunchy, hippy sort of idea, but there is something to be said about it. If you can get enough people to cross the invisible lines of society and stand together, it'll put a crack in the wall.

~EEE~
[User Picture]From: secret_stuff
2008-03-28 05:40 pm (UTC)

Re: Good points

(Link)

Absolutely, I don't mean to advocate that nothing will ever change, so nothing should even be tried, just that some realistic expectations should be had. Just because it will never be perfect, doesn't mean you can't make it better.

But by the same token, I tend to think that makes putting all your eggs in one basket to be tricky. While there is plenty of work to be done, I don't forsee the idea of racism or prejudice ever going away entirely, but it can certainly be mitigated.

My observation is that a problem like racism exists on multiple levels - it can be a problem in and of itself, and it can also be a symptom of other problems. You can potentially mitigate or even possibly eradicate the former, but the latter not so much unless you also have someone dealing with the underlying problems.